Defense rubric

My Name: Dannaie

Defender: Ashley        Song: Drops of Jupiter                       Artist: Train

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Pretty good pretty good, love this song, love this band, awesome all around.	1	2	3
PATHOS	You need to explain to me in a sense that makes ME feel emotional, not to explain how they make it emotions.	1	2	3
LOGOS	No song truly needs logic, but very nice.	1	2	3
Feedback	Need to convince the song, not explain it.		TOTAL	6/9

Defender: Doug          Song: American Pie               Artist: Don Mclean

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Good facts and nice presentation.	1	2	3
PATHOS	I like how you bring your childhood into the discussion to represent emotion.	1	2	3
LOGOS	The background information and facts behind the song was good.	1	2	3
Feedback	Overall nice job.		TOTAL	9 /9

Defender: Seth            Song: Valley of the kings      Artist: Gamma ray

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Good defense on the song.	1	2	3
PATHOS	I liked how you linked your novel writing with the song and that this song inspires you.	1	2	3
LOGOS	German band that sings in English, I learned a lot.	1	2	3
Feedback	I liked the emotional connection along with the facts about the song. It was cool that you merged it all into one.		TOTAL	9 /9

Defender: Jamie          Song: Never grow up             Artist: Taylor Swift

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Personal connection, family	1	2	3
PATHOS	Relatable to everyone	1	2	3
LOGOS	Chart position	1	2	3
Feedback	Good song, nice relevance		TOTAL	7/9

Defender: Zack sicard            Song: Crash into me  Artist: Dave Matthews

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Good communication	1	2	3
PATHOS	Good personal connection and relationship connection	1	2	3
LOGOS	Nice facts about the artist	1	2	3
Feedback	Good information and nice job relating it to real life situations		TOTAL	9/9

Defender: Bobby        Song: Lose yourself               Artist: Eminem

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Good relating to it	1	2	3
PATHOS	It’s nice to know it helped you through  a tough time	1	2	3
LOGOS	Chart position	1	2	3
Feedback	I like the song and the fact you used this song to put to modern day times		TOTAL	8/9

Defender: Taylor         Song: Sweet Caroline                        Artist:

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Nice facts and how it’s symbolic	1	2	3
PATHOS	Not a lot of pathos	1	2	3
LOGOS	Good relevance	1	2	3
Feedback	I liked finding out something new about a song that I’ve heard a hundred times, nice job.		TOTAL	7/9

Defender: Ashely          Song: Big Yellow Taxi             Artist:

Persuasion	EXAMPLE	LIMITED	POTENT	EXEMPLARY
ETHOS	Good ethos	1	2	3
PATHOS	Nice pathos	1	2	3
LOGOS	I heard the other band singing that, not this artist	1	2	3
Feedback	Nice song and good explanation of the song, good job		TOTAL	9/9